The Nostalgic Referent: Photography, Simulation, and the Fate of “Cela a été”
Bertillon’s police mugshots. AI image Introduction: The Return of the Real The renewed exaltation of the photographic referent, particularly in current debates around synthetic imagery, reactivates a familiar anxiety about the status of visual truth. As new technologies appear, one feature of the previous medium is usually amplified and repositioned; in the present moment, the referent has been elevated to a criterion of legitimacy. Analogue traces and digital captures are invoked as guarantors of authenticity against images produced by generative models. Yet this intensified longing for the “that-has-been” can be illuminated through a different conceptual lens: Jean Baudrillard’s theory of the simulacrum. Baudrillard describes four regimes of the image, not as a chronological history but as logical modes of relating appearance to the real. Used heuristically, these regimes clarify how photography has shifted, from its evidentiary origins to its artistic manipulations and, now, its...